Sunday, August 17, 2008

24

I have finally bowed to peer pressure and started watching 24. I just finished the second season Saturday night (or should I say Sunday morning at 3am) and so far I have really enjoyed it. It is one of those shows that is very addicting, especially since I have the whole season at my house, and as a result, I watch 4 or 5 episodes in a row when I get a chance.

The show is a little unrealistic in some places however. I just don't think that anyone would or could break that many laws in the span of 24 hours. This was especially true in the first season when Jack escaped from police, then Secret Service, then police custody all in the span of 2 hours!

It is a thought provoking show, even when it blurs the line between reality and fantasy. Which leads me to the point of this blog... torture.

I know, I know... you didn't see that one coming at all did you! But bear with me for a moment. In the second season, a nuclear bomb is going to explode somewhere in LA. ( I will avoid the obvious jokes about improving the air quality, not to mention traffic, as I would like to stay on topic as much as possible).  Jack's mission is to find the bomb before it goes off... in less that 24 hours. In the end, the bomb is found and L.A. is saved but in order to accomplish this, no less than 4 people are tortured.

So here is the questions that I have heard many times posed to many politicians, "If a nuclear bomb was going to go off in the U.S. and the only way to stop it was to torture a terrorist, would you do it?"

There are generally two different answers tot his questions. The first is "Of course we would do whatever we had to to save American lives. If that means torturing a few terrorists, all the better!" The second is "Absolutely not. If we did then we are no better than the terrorist who we are fighting against and heaven forbid one of us is ever captured, what makes us think that we won't be subject to the same treatment!" One is the hawk and one is the dove. One is a crazy conservative and the other is a bleeding heart liberal. But which one are you?

As I said above, I have heard this question posed many times before without think much of it. I always thought it was a question asked to trap the democrat into sounding unpatriotic because they wouldn't torture any one, even a terrorist. But after watching 24, I am unsure what I would do. How can you not do whatever you can to save millions of people? Doesn't the safety of the group out weight the safety of the individual? It seems to be a simple answer and yet is is hardly that.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Good post, Pete, and a very interesting question you pose. I'm not sure what the "correct" answer is, or even one even exists. I suppose each person has to search his or her conscience--as looking in the mirror is tough every day if one isn't true to oneself. That said, I'd have to lean towards torture, as the lives of the MANY probably take precedent over the life of the one. I'd definitely avoid mirrors, though.